Skip to content
Cost & Benefits

Sag Harbor vs Shelter Island

Simple answer

We can't estimate the monthly savings.

The Census Bureau did not publish typical rent for Shelter Island. We will not fill that in.

Sag Harbor

New York

Typical rent
$3,501
Typical pay
$129,821 a year
2-bedroom fair rent
$2,689
Price index
112.6 (metro)

Shelter Island

New York

Typical rent
Not published
Typical pay
$165,734 a year
2-bedroom fair rent
$2,689
Price index
112.6 (metro)

Benefits after a move

Sag Harbor and Shelter Island are in the same state, so the benefit rules do not change when you move between them.